Direct vs. Indirect Procurement: Understanding the Differences

05 - March - 2023

The simplest definition of procurement is finding and securing the goods and services required to support a company's ongoing operations and output. Direct and indirect methods are the two main types of procurement.

There aren't many differences between the two things at first glance. Both require comparing prices from negotiating terms, and vendors, managing connections, authorizing invoices, and maintaining records. Indirect versus direct procurement, however, has different procedures.

The importance of one may outweigh the other for your company, even though both may be significant depending on the sector or the product. Whichever method your company chooses to prioritize, it's critical to comprehend the differences between them.

So let's examine the interpretations of indirect and direct procurement, look at a few examples of each, and then contrast the implications of each.


What is Direct Procurement?

Direct procurement is defined as the process of purchasing goods and services related to the production of a company's products. These goods and services are useful in the manufacturing process and are directly incorporated into the finished product.

Examples of Direct Procurement:

● Purchasing raw materials from a supplier to manufacture a product.

● Buying equipment or machinery useful for production or manufacturing purposes.

● Obtaining office supplies for a company's administrative needs, including furniture, computers, and stationery.

● Acquiring software or technology tools required for the company's operations.

● Acquiring services from a third-party supplier to satisfy business requirements like logistics, transportation, or advertising.

Benefits and Challenges of Direct Procurement

● Benefits of Direct Procurement
Managing the quality and supply of raw materials and components is one of the main advantages of direct procurement for businesses. Businesses can control the risks associated with supply chain disruptions and ensure they receive high-quality products by maintaining direct supplier relationships. By negotiating bulk pricing agreements with suppliers, direct procurement can also assist businesses in cost reduction.

● Challenges of Direct Procurement

The need for extensive planning and coordination is one of the difficulties with direct procurement. Due to the need to make sure that products are available when required, the timing of raw material deliveries and production schedules must be carefully managed. Furthermore, companies relying heavily on direct procurement may be more susceptible to supply chain disruptions due to natural disasters or geopolitical events.


What is Indirect Procurement?

A business's infrastructure is indirect procurement. It entails spending money on the daily goods, services, and resources needed to maintain a business. Even though purchases made through indirect procurement don't frequently show up in a company's net profit, productivity is only possible with these operations.

Examples of Indirect Procurement:

● Purchasing office cleaning services or janitorial supplies for maintaining the cleanliness of the workplace.

● Procuring professional services such as legal, accounting, or consulting services for business operations.

● Acquiring IT services such as hosting, cloud storage, or cybersecurity solutions.

● Purchasing office utilities such as electricity, water, or gas.

● Obtaining travel services such as flights, hotel stays, and car rentals for business purposes.

● Procuring employee benefits such as insurance, retirement plans, or wellness programs.

● Purchasing marketing services such as market research, advertising, or public relations.


Benefits and Challenges of Indirect Procurement

Benefits of Indirect Procurement

The ability to lower operating costs for businesses is among the main advantages of indirect procurement. Businesses can get discounts on office supplies and IT equipment by negotiating volume pricing agreements with suppliers. Employers can concentrate on their core competencies by outsourcing non-core tasks like payroll and human resources.

Challenges of Indirect Procurement

One of the challenges of indirect procurement is that it can take time to measure the return on investment (ROI) associated with these purchases. Unlike direct procurement, which is directly tied to the production of a company's products, the benefits of indirect procurement can be more difficult to quantify. Additionally, managing many indirect suppliers can be time-consuming and resource-intensive.


What Differentiates Direct and Indirect Procurement?

Direct purchases are used directly in the production of the final product, whereas indirect purchasing is more related to support. While this distinction in function might not seem that significant at first glance, where we really start to see the difference is how businesses operate direct versus indirect procurement.

Lets see some of the key differences that separate direct and indirect procurement:

Supplier Relationships

An important distinction between direct and indirect procurement is the emphasis on vendor relationships. By using a variety of suppliers and industries, indirect procurement entails buying non-essential goods. You might not always purchase your office supplies from the same vendor, instead searching for the best deal.

The importance of establishing enduring, long-term relationships with indirect procurement suppliers may be reduced. It's crucial to concentrate on creating enduring connections with direct procurement suppliers.

These connections are essential for managing your supply chain because they guarantee a steady flow of supplies that will keep your company operating smoothly and benefit your vendors' operations. You can safeguard your supply chain by spending money on these vendor relationships.

Inventory Management

Indirect and direct procurement also differ in terms of inventory management. For indirect procurement, having a fully developed inventory management plan is often unnecessary since these materials contribute to daily business operations rather than core production.

For example, department managers can track and order office supplies as needed instead of developing a formal tracking system. On the other hand, direct procurement requires more focus on inventory management as it involves the raw materials necessary for producing products and services.

Businesses often develop strategic plans for managing direct procurement inventory, including tracking material usage, setting budgets, acquiring storage space, and establishing a system for ordering additional materials. Effective inventory management is crucial for meeting production requirements and ensuring smooth business operations.

Procurement Strategies

Managing direct spending is crucial for any business to maintain profitability, which is why many organizations have a dedicated team to handle it. Any disruptions in the supply chain can lead to production delays and financial losses, so direct procurement is thoroughly budgeted and planned.

In contrast, indirect procurement is typically more relaxed, with responsibilities split across different teams in the company. These supplies are often a low priority and unpredictable, so teams may only purchase them as needed. However, those making these decisions may not be procurement experts and may need to gain knowledge of each expense category.

This is where third-party services like P3 can help implement the best procurement strategies for indirect spending.

Organizational Structure

Direct procurement is critical to a business's success, so it is common to have a dedicated department to manage it within the organizational structure. This department is responsible for monitoring inventory and budget requirements, building relationships with key vendors, and communicating supply needs.

However, most businesses do not need a centralized department to handle their indirect procurement needs. Instead, individual department managers oversee their team's indirect procurement needs, allowing them to assess their own material requirements and request supplies as needed.

A less formal approach ensures that employees can focus on essential responsibilities rather than spending time navigating formal procurement structures.

Planned Spending

The direct procurement procedure is typically consistent and auditable. To prevent supply chain disruptions, it is vital to schedule and budget for the key inputs necessary for maintaining things running smoothly well in advance. Deliveries are frequently scheduled with important suppliers by procurement professionals.

In contrast, it can be challenging to determine precise numbers for indirect supplies and gauge demand for items like office supplies.

As a result, indirect procurement is less planned for or budgeted for. Since, direct supplies are a scheduled step in the procurement process, indirect supplies are typically acquired impulsively when needed.


What to Choose?

Your business needs software that will give you a dedicated team to look after your inventory, spending, and relationships with important vendors so that you can meet your direct procurement needs. Your supply chain needs to be optimized for efficient operations.

Your company can benefit from the in-depth market expertise, tried-and-true tactics, and affordable solutions provided by software like BusinessBid for direct and indirect procurement, ensuring that you get the best deals possible. They can assist your company in developing and putting into practice strategies to simplify your procurement procedures, boost efficiency, and reduce cost due to their extensive experience and expertise in the procurement industry.

Chat with us
Get Free Consultancy

Signup Now

Weekly Live Demo: See how BusinessBid Can Enhance Your Procurement Experience. Register Now